Log in

No account? Create an account

Spores, Molds, and Fungus

Pop Culture Miscellania

Previous Entry Share Next Entry
Geek Culture Isn't Mainstream
When people describe geek culture as now being “mainstream” because certain evergreen science fiction and fantasy properties make gobs of cash at the box office and are marketed to every new generation...I disagree.

Fretting over whether something is mainstream or not isn’t the issue: I don’t care if geekdom is mainstream or not. But I still see a partial division between the popularity of genre entertainment, and the “geek culture”.

It’s because of one of the ways people are geeks. It’s not the only way to be a geek, certainly not the “right” way to be a geek, but it’s a way. A distinct way of dealing with media.

Some geeks, you see, they dig deeper. They engage with media that the culture at large has forgotten. They fall in love with minor characters (literally or not). They pick apart every tiny little detail, and then dig up more.

Not every geek does this, but enough do that I feel like, even if Star Wars and Spider-Man are explosively popular, there are these practices common to “geek culture” that the public as a whole doesn’t engage in, and therefore it’s not accurate to say the entire thing has gone mainstream just because certain things geeks like have become popular.
Tags: ,

  • 1
You didn't say in what context the claim of geek being mainstream was made, but I can think of two phenomena that might have been used to support such a claim.

1. Certain aspects of "geek culture" have begun to appear more and more in mainstream media—and are presented more and more without exhaustive explanation. I'm thinking here mostly of things like on-line gaming and LARP.

2. Geeks are no longer relegated to the "quirky but useful sidekick" role ( or the "conveniently twisted serial killer, for that matter.) Whatever your opinion of the show, I think of The Big Bang Theory as a "mainstream" show that put geeks front and center.

I've seen it in a bunch of places lately: the last part was on a podcast, which made the statement that geek culture was "mainstream" because superhero movies and Star Wars were popular with large parts of the culture. But those two points have, of course, been used to support the notion at different places.

But none of them touch on this phenomenon that I talked about, which is why I don't think it's necessarily true.

  • 1